Saatva VS Cocoon: Which Mattress Is Better?

Saatva and Cocoon by Sealy are two top-performing sleep brands, offering high-quality mattresses that rival each other in popularity but differ in almost every way. It’s important to consider these differences before choosing between them.

The Saatva mattress is a luxury hybrid mattress designed and handcrafted in the United States using consciously-sourced materials. It features some customizable options, including comfort level and mattress height.

Cocoon is the bed-in-a-box brand from the seasoned sleep experts at Sealy. Cocoon offers a memory foam mattress called the Chill Mattress that tackles temperature regulation head-on with a variety of heat mitigating technologies.

Both the Saatva mattress and the Chill mattress from Cocoon by Sealy are fantastic options, but because they are so different, they will appeal to different kinds of customers. This article will provide an in-depth mattress comparison and explain the differences between the two options so that you can determine the best mattress for you.

What’s the Difference Between the Saatva Mattress and the Cocoon Mattress?

There is no such thing as the perfect mattress for everyone. Each of us has different preferences and needs, such as heat regulation or pressure relief. If you share the mattress with a partner, you also need to consider what they are looking for in a mattress. Keep these aspects in mind as you read through the similarities and differences between Cocoon by Sealy and Saatva.

Mattress Designs Compared

The Saatva mattress is a hybrid innerspring mattress made with CertiPur-US certified materials. It features a five-layer construction:

• Euro Pillow Top – Varies in plushness based on your comfort preference and offers even more comfort than a standard pillow top.
• Dual Perimeter Edge Support – Sturdy foam layers line the edges of the Saatva classic mattress to prevent sagging and extend the sleep surface.
• Pocket Comfort Coils – Individually-wrapped coils provide responsive support and encourage healthy airflow through the mattress.
• Back Support Enhancement Layer – Active wire lumbar zone technology plus premium memory foam combine to soothe pressure on the spine.
• Steel Innersprings – a base layer of tempered steel innersprings makes up the second half of Saatva’s dual coil system to ensure a long-lasting mattress that won’t sag.

The Chill mattress from Cocoon by Sealy is a memory foam mattress featuring a three-layer construction:

• Memory Foam Top Layer – Conforms to your body, hugging your curves, and providing the perfect support for your sleep position.
• Comfort Layer – Comes in your choice of medium-soft or extra firm depending on your sleep preferences.
• High-Density Foam Base Layer – This sturdy and robust foam layer acts as a stable base for the mattress and ensures durability.

Consensus: The Saatva mattress and the Cocoon mattress are two entirely different types of mattresses. Those who prefer the enveloping, body-contouring comfort of memory foam should choose the Chill Mattress from Cocoon by Sealy. Those who prefer the luxurious feel of a pillow top or the springiness of a hybrid mattress should choose the Saatva classic mattress.

Mattress Cover Comparison

The Saatva mattress features an organic cotton cover with a damask bronze trim that is also organic. It has been treated with Guardin botanical antimicrobial fabric treatment to help it stay fresh and healthy. It cannot be removed or machine washed.

The Cocoon mattress is topped with a stretch knit cover made of a synthetic blend. It is infused with proprietary phase change material, which absorbs and transfers heat so that the mattress surface stays cool to the touch. Like the Saatva mattress cover, it cannot be removed and can only be spot cleaned.

Consensus: Both mattress covers are good for hot sleepers, thanks to the PCM in the Cocoon cover and the organic cotton in the Saatva cover. However, those with sensitive skin are better off choosing the Saatva mattress, as organic cotton is less likely to trigger allergies and is also better at wicking away moisture.

Feel & Firmness of Saatva VS Cocoon

The Saatva mattress is available in three comfort levels: plush soft, luxury firm, and firm. However, even the firmest option offers a luxurious feel thanks to the Euro pillow top. The dual spring system makes it good at both heat regulation and motion isolation, although it does offer a hint of bounce. This mattress has excellent edge support making it easy to get in and out of bed and provides a maximum amount of sleep surface.

Customers can also choose their preferred comfort level with the Chill mattress from Cocoon by Sealy. The Medium-firm option offers more of an “in-the-bed” feeling, while the Extra Firm option provides an “on-the-bed” feeling. Like most memory foam mattresses, the Cocoon mattress absorbs shock, making it good at motion cancellation, but eliminating bounce. Memory foam also provides weaker edge support than the Saatva mattress.

Consensus: Both mattresses cater to all types of sleepers and sleep positions by offering customizable comfort levels. The Saatva mattress might be a better option for couples because of its wider sleep surface, bounce, and breathability.

Sizes & Prices Compared

The Saatva classic mattress comes in eight sizes, including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Split King, Cal King, and Split Cal King. Customers can also choose between two mattress heights, 11.5” and 14.5”. The Saatva mattress starts at $799 for a twin and costs $1,399 for a queen. For a luxury mattress made with premium materials, this is a fair and competitive price.

The Cocoon mattress is available in six sizes including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King. It starts at $730 for a twin and costs $930 for a queen.

Consensus: Hybrid mattresses are almost always more expensive than memory foam mattresses due to their more complex constructions. This is part of the reason that the Saatva mattress is slightly more expensive than the Cocoon mattress. Both are reasonably priced, though Saatva beats Cocoon in value for money. Choose Saatva if you are looking for the best deal or if you have a split-sized bed.

Trial Periods & Warranty

Saatva offers customers a 180-night trial period and a 15-year warranty. Returns during the trial period incur a $99 fee for transport and labor.

Cocoon offers a 100-night trial period and a 15-year warranty. Returns during the trial period are free.

Consensus: The Chill mattress from Cocoon by Sealy may be the best mattress for a first-time or tentative mattress buyer, who might want to take advantage of Cocoon’s easy return policy. However, Saatva’s 15-year warranty makes it a better option for someone looking for a mattress that will last a long time.

Shipping & Installation

The purchase of a Saatva mattress comes with free shipping and free white glove delivery. Unlike other online mattress sellers, Saatva does not compress their mattress and send it in a compact box. However, Saatva’s sleep concierge makes setup and installation easy and will work with you to arrange an ideal time for delivery. Mattress removal is also offered for free upon request.

Cocoon mattresses ship for free to the continental US via UPS Ground and arrives at your door rolled and compressed. During installation, you will need to wait for your mattress to fully decompress before laying on it. You may also notice the slight odor of off-gassing, which is harmless but can be unpleasant. White glove delivery is available for a fee, otherwise, you do not need to be home for delivery.

Consensus: Saatva has a more stress-free shipping and installation process. Older individuals who might not be fit for heavy lifting should choose a Saatva mattress to take advantage of their free white glove delivery.

Conclusion

Saatva’s luxury hybrid mattress and Cocoon’s memory foam mattress are two top-of-the-line products. However, they benefit different sleepers in different ways. As you shop for your next mattress, use this mattress comparison to better understand the differences between these mattresses and help you decide which is right for you. Finally, don’t forget to read the full mattress reviews for Saatva and Cocoon on our website!